A major debate has started after a transgender woman won the 2025 Sydney Local Woman of the Year award.
Some critics argue that the winner was not born female, making the award controversial. Brianna Skinner, a transgender woman, received the honor this week. The New South Wales (NSW) government gives out these awards every year to recognize women who make a difference in their communities.
Sydney MP Alex Greenwich announced Skinner as his chosen winner. He described her as a “proud transgender woman and a strong supporter of equality.”
Brianna Skinner’s Work for Transgender Rights
Greenwich first met Skinner in 2014 when she and her wife, Nuna, contacted his office. They wanted changes to NSW laws that made it difficult for transgender people to update their identification documents.
“Brianna’s journey of transitioning from male to female showed the discrimination in NSW laws,” Greenwich said. “Our discussion helped shape my Equality Bill.”
Act of Courage During Bondi Junction Attack
In April 2024, Skinner also acted bravely during a stabbing attack at Bondi Junction. She was working as a retail floor manager when the incident happened.
“When she heard unusual noise, Brianna quickly guided 40 customers to the back of the store,” Greenwich shared. “She locked the store and kept everyone calm until police arrived.”
Chili-Eating Contests for Charity
Skinner has also raised money for Soldier On, a group that helps veterans. She took part in chili-eating contests and collected over $3,000 in donations.
Her success led her to South Carolina, where she competed in the World Chili Eating Competition. Greenwich praised her for “bringing people together and promoting inclusivity.”
Public Reaction and Backlash
Even with her achievements, the award sparked criticism.
Activist Kirralie Smith accused officials of “gaslighting” the public. Commentator Prue MacSween said many women would find the award offensive. She added that the award should go to someone who was born female.
Many people online also expressed frustration. One person wrote, “This is an insult to real women.” Another said, “Women don’t accept this as normal.”
Support for Skinner
Not everyone was against the decision. Many people praised Skinner for her bravery and community work.
“Brianna saved lives during the Bondi attack,” one supporter wrote. “She has done a lot to help women.”
Greenwich defended his choice, calling her “one of the strongest people I know.” He said Skinner is committed to helping her community and the city.